The Commonhold and Leasehold Bill has been introduced to Parliament for its First Reading. Credit: Marcin Nowak on Unsplash

Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill: good, bad, unnecessary?

Government has declared war on the 1,000-year-old leasehold system this week, introducing a bill that will see that form of ownership eradicated for future developments. But is its approach the right one? Place Midlands went to the market to find out.

The bill in a nutshell

The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill will…

  • Cap ground rents at £250 a year starting in 2028
  • Reduce ground rents to zero by 2068
  • Removes powers for landlords to take away leaseholders’ homes over small unpaid bills and maintenance charges – instead these disputes will go to court
  • Cap administration fees
  • Ban leasehold for new flats and homes, with commonhold becoming the standard model. Commonhold ownership has no ground rent and no third-party landlord
  • Drop threshold for switching to commonhold in a building from 100% resident support to 50% support. Non-consenting residents are allowed to remain on modified leases until they sell
  • Allow homeowners to buy 990-year lease extensions
  • Strengthen leaseholders’ right to a gigabit broadband connection

The bill has just started its first reading, meaning it has a long way to go before adoption and could change quite a bit between now and then.

Read the bill.

An unnecessary overhaul

“It seems that this is the proverbial sledgehammer to crack a nut,” said Richard Glover, a partner in JMW’s commercial litigation team.

“I agree with everything it’s trying to achieve, it’s just unnecessary,” he added.

Tweaking existing systems, he argued, could deliver the similar results without adding an extra level of uncertainty to a market that is already facing increasing regulatory pressures, including from the Building Safety Act and previously agreed changes to reduce the profitability of ground rent.

“The things they are seeking to resolve by introducing this completely new system – a system that will take lots of time and lots of money and rip up contracts and completely turn everything on its head – the things that this has set out to achieve can be achieved by the current set of legislative tools we have,” Glover said.

He pointed to the fact that commonhold already exists and that people have had the right to switch their ownership to that model. Reducing the threshold for that commonhold switch makes sense, he noted, but did not see why it had to be part of a whole new system.

Leaseholders do run some buildings already, he pointed out. Resident management companies are already in place in some buildings, with leaseholders in place as directors.

“You’ve got that structure, which is essentially commonhold by a different name,” Glover said.

He added that existing legislative changes have already reduced the profitability of holding onto freeholds.

“Owning a freehold when you’re not a leaseholder of a building is more of a liability than a profitmaking business now because of the changes to ground rent and the massive obligations that have been imposed on them by the BSA,” Glover said.

“There is a deterrent in place already for landlords to retain freeholds and treat them as a cash cow.”

Leigh Shapiro, partner at Winckworth Sherwood, agreed. The Ground Rent Act of 2022 had already put the end to ground rents for most new long residential leasehold properties, she said.

The developments of today are already working with the basis that they’ll be run by leaseholders anyway, Shapiro said.

“They’re only now beginning to finish developments, so we haven’t yet seen the full impact of that act,” she said.

Glover was frustrated that the conversation around this bill has been reduced to landlords, managing agents equal bad and leaseholders equal good.

“There are a lot of bad managing agents out there – there are some terrible ones,” he conceded. “But there are a lot of really, really good ones.”

“The cure for this, and is already something that is coming in, is regulation of managing agents. If you get the cowboys out of the industry, then the statutory control that is currently in place should be followed by professional managing agents,” Glover said.

“It gets rid of opaque service charges and people taking secret commissions – that can be resolved.”

Will it reduce costs for leaseholders?

Shapiro was not sold that moving to commonhold would make things any better, necessarily, for leaseholders as the reasons costs have gone up have not been solely landlord-driven.

Cladding remediation, rising insurance costs, and increasing staff salary demands will not be going away simply because someone has the commonhold of their flat, she said.

“People feel this will be a lot cheaper and easier – I don’t think this will do that,” she said.

“I don’t think the cost of managing a building will go down compared to a well-managed property run now. I think people need to be honest with what the cost will be and what they will need to pay in the future.”

Glover agreed.

“It’s not the landlords fault that the cost of repairing and running a building has gone up, that’s happening across the board,” Glover said.

The cost of change

Confusion and delay will result in increasing costs, Glover warned. People will need to get to grips with what these changes mean and that will take time.

It may also see a diminishing interest in building commonhold developments, or increases to apartment prices to make up for the lack of ground rent income.

Shapiro did not forecast as much of an impact, noting that the Ground Rent Act had already caused developers to factor in the loss of ground rent income.

However, while it may not put a standstill on development, it certainly will not be helping get projects off the ground.

“What it will affect is confidence in what is being sold and marketed and how the conveying works on that,” she said.

She added: “It’s a really significant change for the sector, where everyone across the board in the sector is going to have to have a good understanding of the changes being brought in – from the developers to the end purchasers to those marketing it to property managers.”

Suzanne Benson, national head of real estate at Trowers & Hamlins, was similarly cautious.

“The publication of the bill signals the next step in the Government’s plan to bring about a seismic change in the way we buy and occupy homes,” she said.

“A lot of the underlying policy drivers are positive with consumer-focused moves to seek to reduce the cost of living in apartments. The challenge remains in the implementation – ongoing maintenance of apartment blocks remains costly and mortgage funding for commonhold is still not widely available.

Benson continued: “At Trowers, our big question, however, focuses on development funding – leasehold structures remain widely used to attract funding to the residential sector and commonhold does create new challenges for the sector to adapt to. This will need to be an important part of the conversation as the bill moves through Parliament.”

Another possible problem…

For Shapiro, there’s an untested element of the government’s commonhold push – can neighbours actually get along?

“It relies on people volunteering to run the building in a proper way,” she noted.

She pointed to the working bill’s wording around how directors of residential-run management companies can enforce decisions that are in the best interest of the majority of unit holders… or choose not to if it would be more “harmonious” to do so.

“Things like that will make it quite difficult to manage these buildings, where you have different people with different interests living next to each other,” Shapiro said.

In her mind, making commonhold the sole option may not be the best idea, and some groups may prefer having a third-party buffer between them and their neighbour.

But as she said before, it is a waiting game to see how the bill actually shapes up and how it gets implemented.

A developer’s point of view

While the lawyers Place spoke to were more cautious about the change, Greg Malouf, chief executive of housebuilder Romal Capital was decidedly more optimistic.

“Any reform that reduces the overall cost of homeownership is a positive step for both homeowners and the wider property industry,” he said.

“In particular, we believe that ground rents have, in many cases, become unnecessarily excessive, placing an additional financial burden on homeowners without delivering any tangible benefit. Measures to address these costs are long overdue and will help make apartment ownership fairer, more affordable and more attractive to future buyers.”

He did, however, agree with the push for more detail.

“As the industry moves towards a commonhold model, it is important that the transition is carefully managed, with clear guidance for developers, lenders, managing agents and homeowners,” he said.

“The practical and financial responsibilities of maintaining complex residential buildings must remain at the heart of any new framework.

“Ultimately, a property market that puts homeowners first, reduces unnecessary costs, and builds greater confidence in apartment ownership is good for everyone. We see these reforms as a positive opportunity to strengthen the industry and support the continued regeneration of our cities.”

Related Articles

Subscribe for free

Stay updated on the latest news and views in property in the Midlands

Subscribe

Keep updated on the latest news, deals, views and opportunities in the Midlands property industry, in your inbox.

By subscribing, you are agreeing to Place Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.